Sunday, April 29, 2012

Chapter 15- Guidelines for Using Evidence in Argument

I think we can all agree that when giving a speech you won't get far if you don't use evidence correctly. Our book perfectly summarizes all the things to keep in mind when presenting evidence. First your evidence needs to be relevant to your topic. There is nothing worse than leave your audience trying to connect the dots between your topic and the evidence you are using. I know sometimes is hard to find evidence that relates exactly to what you are talking about, but I always try to  find a direct link between them two. Second, your evidence needs to be drawn from highly credible sources. The truth is that I highly doubt that  someone in your audience will cross-check your sources during or after your speech; but you never know especially with the technology we have nowadays. People can now look up anything on their smart phones and you definitely don't want to be called on not having good sources. Besides it is the speakers responsibility to make sure he is providing his/her audience with the best information possible. Third, you need to get your evidence from diverse sources. The risk that you take by only getting your information from one source or similar sources is that your argument could be one sided. Also, you might not be prepared for the opposition that your audience might present. Finally, it is important to incorporate evidence addressing all types of appeals. Many speakers think that if they rely completely on logic or emotions it will get them the result they want. That is not correct, we as human beings, are not one dimensional, this meaning that we think using various aspects of who we are. That is why is so important to make sure as the speaker, that we address Pathos, Logos and Mythos.

Friday, April 27, 2012

Persuasive Discussion

Recently I had to present an argument for my debate class where I would try to persuade my audience to change their minds on a controversial subject. I ended up doing mine on "Spanking should not be considered child abuse"; I'm not one to toot my own horn but I think I did a pretty good job. I started the speech establishing my credibility; given that I was spanked when I was a child and I turned out to be pretty disciplined and responsible, I think my credibility was somewhat high. I also used a lot on "logos", I had a lot of statistics and material from studies. I decided to have a more rational approach to this topic, because it seemed like the opposition based their argument more on "Pathos" (emotions). Even though I did have some inductive reasoning by asking my audience to see how many people that have been spanked actually turn out to be more disciplined in life; I tried to be careful to clarified this is not the rule. The problem with spanking and these sort of topics is that people will respond differently to your speech based on their own experience; being aware of this I tried to show both scenarios and both views and let the audience decide (of course I tried to make my side stronger :). Finally I feel my speech was a success, given that many from my audience agreed with me at the end and the ones that did not, did see the strength on my claim.

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

Speech Buddy Videos Chapter 15" pros and cons of home schooling

I liked both arguments presented by Dixie and Robert. They were both very assertive and well informed, and it definitely showed in the way they backed up their argument. I think strong evidence from reliable sources it's an essential part of a successful persuasive speech and they both had that. However, even though I liked both speeches I thought Robert's speech was stronger. His arguments were a bit more valid in my opinion. Also, I think Dixie made a huge mistake (and personally it is something I cannot stand on people trying to make a case), she exaggerated and generalized. You can say with certainty that all public school are "prisons" or all have a violent and unsafe environmental.  When she mentioned that as part of the argument I knew this was a slippery-slope; she can't just say that by homeschooling your kids you are "saving" their lives. On top of that she implied that the "American teenager" experience is "how to sell drugs" and how to "duck under your desk" in case one of your classmates starts killing everyone. I'm sorry but this was just not the right thing to say if you are trying to make a logical argument. In conclusion I learned a lot on what to do from Robert and a few things to avoid from Dixie.

Sunday, April 22, 2012

The Ethics of Persuasive Speaking: Persuasion or Manipulation?

To might this is one of the biggest issues with public speaking nowadays.  I feel that every time we need to make an important decision, especially as a nation, we find ourselves listening to extremely convincing people, but are they truthful?? I have to admit that I've become more skeptical as I've gotten older, and I'm definitely incredulous when elections come around. The book says that every ethical speaker must meet the National Communication Association's standards of ethical communication and they must adhere to the following principle "We condemn communication that degrades individuals and humanity through distortion, intimidation, coercion, and violence, and through the expression of intolerance and hatred" (Coopman, 292). I think this is a great principle, but it makes me wonder: Has this been said to political figures??? All I know is that showing both sides of the story is the right thing to do. Even if your audience loved your speech and the ended up agreeing with you; if you didn't give the  whole truth, you have nothing to be proud of. Being persuasive is all about being able to come up with an argument with better bases, to be able to show that while your opponents might also have a point, you have a "better one". All I know is that being manipulative is always easier.

Thursday, April 19, 2012

A Sea of Pesuasion


While reading this question I could not help but think… Wow I'm really bombarded by persuasive messages, especially this semester. I'm currently taking five different communication classes and they all deal with persuasion one way or another. Even though it can be somewhat stressful having to come up with so many different speeches; I'm pleased that I've gotten to hear some many different points of view and even be informed of topics that I've never heard before. Also, my comm 15 class (Mass Communication) has opened my eyes of how influenced we are by the media. I great example of this it's the project I worked on recently, it is incredible how different media sources can portray the same story in completely different lighting. For my Comm 10 class I had to get different articles about Treyvon Martin case; for those who are not familiar with the story, Treyvon was an African American 15 year-old kid that was shot by George Zimmerman a community night watchman. Zimmerman claimed that he had shot Martin on self defense; the controversy around the situation is to determine if Zimmerman actually acted on self-defense or it is just another case of hate-crime. What I discovered by the articles I read is that media does not care that much anymore about getting the whole story. Also, usually if the newspaper or media source was more on the conservative side, they would sympathize more with Zimmerman. On the other hand if the medium was more liberal, they would tend to portray Martin as a victim. All this research made me wonder if we ever get non biased information? I'm starting to see that we don't. Communication in many aspect is only a persuasion game.

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Monroe's Motivated Sequence and the Problem/Solution organizational pattern

Monroe's Motivated Sequence and the Problem/Solution are both great ways to organize a persuasive speech but with two completely different approaches. To me Monroe's focuses more on Pathos or feelings. The way is set up with its 5 steps: Attention, Need/Want, Satisfaction, Visualization and Action, it is intended to evoke a strong emotion on the audience. Even though the Monroe's Motivated Sequence seems like the way to go, especially if you are talking about a controversial topic(which is the case with my upcoming persuasive speech), there are a lot of mistakes that if you are not aware of could cost you your speech. According Mike Berry's website from the San Juan Unified School District, one of the thing you need to establish from the get go when using MMS is if you want to present your topic as a need or as a want. The website says: "A need, according to Webster, is a "necessity". A want, is a "desire for", but why is it important to note this different? well, if you present a need as a want or vice versa, your audience might feel offended or might not perceive the overall importance of what you are trying to tell them. Another thing to watch out for when using MMS is to make sure your solution and call for action is reasonable. If the solution you are implying is not doable and practical for your audience, your speech will lose its purpose. Now moving on to the Problem/Solution organizational pattern, this pattern is a bit more straight forward than MMS, I think this pattern is ideal if you feel that you won't face much opposition from your audience. It will be very useful if you're exposing a topic that is easily recognized by your audience and when you wish to focus more on the solution rather than convincing your audience that there is a problem. Personally, for the topic I will be doing for my persuasive speech I need to get a strong emotional reaction from the  audience and I believe the Monroe's Motivated Sequence would help me get that.

Sunday, April 15, 2012

Responding calmly to a hostile audience member

Sometimes we found ourselves giving a speech or presentation on a subject that might be controversial and evoke a strong reaction from the audience. I believe responding calmly to someone in the audience that might strongly disagree takes tact. Even if that person is trying to provoke you using emotionally charged language is your responsibility as the speaker to stay calm and handle the situation accordingly. Asking the person respectfully to maybe use a different way to address you, letting them know in a polite way that you acknowledged their point of view, and maybe asking them polity to talk you after the speech, are ways to avoid confrontations that might hurt your speech.

Sexist Language

I've seen this same topic pop up on all of my communication classes this semester. Obviously it's a subject of high importance and I think it's mainly due to the women's empowerment  movement. I as a woman can see why it is important to sometimes use gender neutral language but as mention on the Flickr's blog I believe is being blown out of proportion. I believe that using nonsexist language in certain setting is essential; for example when giving a speech in front of a college student audience you have to be extremely careful with this kind of thing. College student audiences tend to notice if you said "chairman" instead of "chairperson" or if you said "husband and wife" instead or "wife and husband". If you think about it an older generations (from the 50's and above) don't pay much attention to this. We need to understand that casual language will never be completely proper is always going to have idioms, euphemisms and cliches. It is up to our better knowledge to know when and where it is appropriate.  Going back to the Flickr's "conversation" I think such an informal website is not the place to be asking for such as rules. The "web-world" has always been characterized for its informality and its spontaneity and I think it should stay that way, after all society will always need outlets for free expression.

Saturday, April 14, 2012

Speech Buddy Videos Chapter 10 &12

The speech buddy videos for these chapters contained a lot of useful, but what I found most important was the use of language. Language is a huge part of our lives, it determines relationships, how you relate to others and also how you present yourself. Knowing how to use language effectively under any situation is something that can  improve your life radically. If we think of great speakers such as Steve Jobs, designer and inventor of Apple, we can see how every word he used was carefully selected in order to reach his audience. He also seemed very friendly and approachable every time he spoke. This is the kind of connection you want  to have with your audience, you want to be seen by your audience as trust worthy and sympathetic; How do you do that?? The videos gave perfect examples of how to do that. First of all you have to use inclusive language; this is very important given that you want every member of your audience to feel included and to feel that you want to be heard by every one of them. You also need to avoid any kind of language that might have a bad connotation. For example using words that are gender related is not a good idea. You want to use words that are gender neutral; For example if you want to refer to a "firemen" is better if you refer to it as "firefighter" or if you want to talk about a "waitress" is better if you refer to it as a "server". Other thing that I tend to pay a lot of attention to is race, especially here in this country. You definitely want to be careful how to refer to people's race.  Many people refer to most of Asian people as "Chinese", this term is definitely not acknowledging the broad number of countries and  cultures in Asia. These kind of mistakes can really hurt your credibility in front of your audience even if you did not mean to offend anyone.
The speech buddy videos also talked about practicing you speech, to me personally, there was nothing new that I am not doing already to practice my speech but it was nice to see that I'm in the right path.

Sunday, April 1, 2012

Informative Speech- Self-Evaluation

For this speech I was determined to pick something I knew extremely well. I thought that by knowing the topic well I could focus more on some other aspects of the speech. By choosing Financial Aid as my topic I knew I had the information down, so I focused more on the delivery of my speech and the media presentation. I believe this is my best speech so far; in my opinion I improved a lot of the things that were pointed out by the teacher and classmates on previous speeches. I think my attention getter was way better; I tried to do something more creative and used a story to engage the audience. It seemed to have worked because I received a lot of positive feedback on it. I also made sure  that I address the "whole" audience and not just one side. Another thing that was pointed out by many was my "posture". I tend to cross my legs when I'm nervous I guess that is how I prevent myself from shaking. This time I was more conscious of my body language and even though I did cross them at the beginning of the speech I was immediately aware of it.

Although I did improve on many of the aspects where I was failing, I repeated some of the same mistakes I had done in previous speeches. For some reason I've been having a hard time keeping my information short enough so I don't go over the assigned time limit. I've tried to keep my information concise but I'm always afraid that I'm leaving vital information out. That was my biggest problem this time I went a minute and a half over the time limit. I also keep using "fillers", I keep saying "umm" a lot and I'm not even noticing it.

The addition of the media presentation also presented a new challenge. I included too many words on the slides and I noticed that by doing that you feel tempted to just read off of them. Also; your audience doesn't want to read the information from your PowerPoint presentation, the rather hear it from you. In conclusion, your presentation media is suppose to enhance your speech not become the center of it.

For my upcoming speeches I plan on making sure I have just the essential information so I don't go over the time limit. I plan on being more aware of my posture, the usage of vocal fillers, eye contact with the whole audience, and the citing of sources. I will try to make my PowerPoint presentation more "audience friendly", only including the necessary information so it doesn't overpower what I'm saying. Given that I did make eye contact with the whole class I give myself an 8 on eye contact. Overall I felt good about this speech. There are still a lot of things I need to improve; but the fact that I wasn't as nervous and the fact that I'm becoming more aware of my flaws shows growth. Taking into account all of this factors I give my performance on the informative speech a B.