Friday, April 27, 2012

Persuasive Discussion

Recently I had to present an argument for my debate class where I would try to persuade my audience to change their minds on a controversial subject. I ended up doing mine on "Spanking should not be considered child abuse"; I'm not one to toot my own horn but I think I did a pretty good job. I started the speech establishing my credibility; given that I was spanked when I was a child and I turned out to be pretty disciplined and responsible, I think my credibility was somewhat high. I also used a lot on "logos", I had a lot of statistics and material from studies. I decided to have a more rational approach to this topic, because it seemed like the opposition based their argument more on "Pathos" (emotions). Even though I did have some inductive reasoning by asking my audience to see how many people that have been spanked actually turn out to be more disciplined in life; I tried to be careful to clarified this is not the rule. The problem with spanking and these sort of topics is that people will respond differently to your speech based on their own experience; being aware of this I tried to show both scenarios and both views and let the audience decide (of course I tried to make my side stronger :). Finally I feel my speech was a success, given that many from my audience agreed with me at the end and the ones that did not, did see the strength on my claim.

4 comments:

  1. It sounds like you really had your stuff together. And spanking children is a really controversial topic in which people can get really opinionated about their stance. Kudos to you for taking a topic like that on. And it sounds like even if you didn't have everyone necessarily agreeing with you, then they at least were able to see eye to eye with your view point. I also think it was wise to invoke logical reasoning to counter the appeals to pathos from your opposition.

    It seems like taking a bajillion speech classes is really working in your favor. I am certainly looking forward to listening to your next speech!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thats a tough topic to tackle, because as you point out this topic provokes an emotional response from people. Some people may have had abusive child hoods or may know others who were abused and may not be able to differentiate the difference between spanking and abuse. While I agree with your view point, I also think there can be a fine line that can easily be over stepped. If a parent is spanking a child when angry for example, they may not realize the strength they are using that may result in bruising or other injuries. I was spanked as a child but never in anger. It was a form of punishment that was used only on occasion after thoroughly being talked to and understanding my punishment. I also think every child is different and therefore respond differently to different types of punishment. For this reason some parents may agree or disagree based on their child's behavior. With a topic like this common ground is extremely important to establish early on. It sounds like you did a good job.

    ReplyDelete
  3. "Have you ever tried simply turning off the TV, sitting down with your children, and hitting them?" Love that line from Futurama. I think you made a wise choice going with the lgical approch. Just based of my opinion and experience it seems that it is a stronger argument. If you have statisticts and facts to back up your side of a debate it doesnt matter how emotional your oponent's argument is, its going to go donw in flames. Showing both sides of your argument was a good idea as well. If you dont show the opostions side it might seem you are overly biased. Obviously you did a great job because the audience agreed with you and even the ones that didnt agree with you did see how well you did supporting your claim.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You are a brave one and kudos to you for picking such a topic. Topics like these are very controversial thus steering many speakers away from them. I happen to be a child that was spanked growing up and I do also agree that I turned out quite well. I have often considered a debate class and reading your post makes me quite interested. I think you took a very smart approach in keeping your position seeming very neutral throwing things in now and again leaning the audience more toward your side. You seem to have displayed a great job reading the audience and adjusting your speech accordingly. It is so interesting to me that an audience can be persuaded into just about anything as long as the information is presented correctly, even if they went into the presentation completely against the topic. I know I am guilty of this for sure! I think your speech topic in this situation may have been one of those times many were persuaded and changed their thinking. I also like that you included statistical data. This is often times quite a shocker to people. The human brain related to numbers in mysterious ways sometimes :)

    ReplyDelete