Wednesday, April 25, 2012
Speech Buddy Videos Chapter 15" pros and cons of home schooling
I liked both arguments presented by Dixie and Robert. They were both very assertive and well informed, and it definitely showed in the way they backed up their argument. I think strong evidence from reliable sources it's an essential part of a successful persuasive speech and they both had that. However, even though I liked both speeches I thought Robert's speech was stronger. His arguments were a bit more valid in my opinion. Also, I think Dixie made a huge mistake (and personally it is something I cannot stand on people trying to make a case), she exaggerated and generalized. You can say with certainty that all public school are "prisons" or all have a violent and unsafe environmental. When she mentioned that as part of the argument I knew this was a slippery-slope; she can't just say that by homeschooling your kids you are "saving" their lives. On top of that she implied that the "American teenager" experience is "how to sell drugs" and how to "duck under your desk" in case one of your classmates starts killing everyone. I'm sorry but this was just not the right thing to say if you are trying to make a logical argument. In conclusion I learned a lot on what to do from Robert and a few things to avoid from Dixie.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Wow, I had just written a great, well thought out comment, and then as I went to check the word count I totally erased it. Winning. o_0
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I initially had the opposite reaction to this set of videos, but both you and Jessamyn made such great points that I have had to rethink my stance on the matter. Dixie does kind of fling some wild claims around that she can't really back up, and even presents a few fallacies. I agree with you Melissa, in that there was some slippery slope action going on there. Just because there have been shootings in a few public schools, it does not mean that every single public school in America is in danger. And whether or not a kid gets into drugs has just as much to do with their home life as it does their social circle.
I think that my initial dislike of Roberts speech came mostly from his content, and not necessarily the structure of his argument. Which, looking back on, is technically better than Dixie's. To me, this just illustrates that you can't rely on your just your topic, or just your technical ability to make your speech work; you need to have them both working congruently.
Have a great weekend!
I agree with your opinion that their firm evidences citing from reliable source, which have effectively supported their support claims. Ideally, I tend to support Dixie's claim, but I really don’t really like her fallacies in hasty generalized reasoning. For example, she said, the 1999 the shooting in Columbine University has shocked families and students to question about the school’s security and safety. This is true, but it doesn’t mean they will consider their children to enroll home schoolings. As you have mentioned that she exaggerated the reasoning. Moreover, when she asserts, “Home schoolings isolate children from the violence in our public schools,” her tone seems that all public schools are full of violent atmosphere. So, in order to protect children, you have to let your children get home schooling education. With in mind, our society, nowadays, has higher rate of violence than public schools; then, you should let your children work at home and totally isolate them don’t leave their houses. I think I have learned some of the common fallacies from her speech.
ReplyDelete